Dwarkesh错了?OpenAI一周克隆Jev
论证要点
- Dwarkesh曾发推质疑RLVR,引发Computer Use从业者不满;但作者亲历Anthropic发布、Claude Cowork播客及OpenAI收购Sky,认为Computer Use已今非昔比。
- Ari Weinstein解释Computer Use与几个月前相比已“180度不同”,智能体现在能调试和从失败中恢复,结合截图、可访问性数据、DOM、Playwright和生成代码改变速度方程。
- OpenAI DevDay发布Dots个人助理、GPT-6.1 Sol模型(成本为Astra的五分之一,Computer Use场景七分之一)、Agents API(含Computer Use)、Decisions API等。
- Decisions API并行推理、无推理过程、模型更小,因此速度极快,但长周期复杂任务能力稍弱;目前只是Luna包装,团队正克隆好模式。
- Nikunj Handa介绍新开发者栈:异步工具调用、中途转向、WebSockets、UltraFast推理、提示缓存、预暖、压缩、Agents API等。
- 讨论涵盖智能体拥有Linux电脑、超越人类使用软件、信任与安全、异步函数调用、实时计算机控制、服务端压缩等。
对实践的启示
对AI应用开发者而言,Computer Use正快速进化,智能体自我调试和恢复能力提升,可结合多种数据源;OpenAI新API栈(异步工具调用、Decisions API等)降低延迟、提升响应,但Decisions API尚不适合长周期复杂任务,需关注信任与安全。
作者承认的反方与局限
作者承认Decisions API目前只是Luna包装,且因模型更小、无推理,在长周期复杂任务上能力稍弱;如何结合不同方法仍是开放研究领域。
原文摘引
Ari explains why Computer Use is now “180 degrees different” from where it was months ago
why it is just a Luna wrapper for now but the team is motivated and egoless enough to clone what they consider to be good patterns.
▸ 展开原文全文(75 段,抓取自 Latent Space)
Three months ago Dwarkesh, who has been posting incredible blogs and episodes about RL, posted a framing question for his video essay on RLVR which upset a lot of Computer Use folks:
We are no strangers to learning in public and are no strangers to the stress of getting things wrong when you have a big platform. However, we were at Anthropic for the Computer Use launch, there for Claude Cowork with the first big podcast on it, organized the first Computer Use track at AIE presenting the state of the art, and were close to the OpenAI-Sky Software acquisition that now powers the complete domination of computer use that Codex enjoys today. This is why we’re excited to bring you today’s first guest, Ari Weinstein, cofounder of Sky and now leading all the amazing CUA progress that casuals might miss:
Ari explains why Computer Use is now “180 degrees different” from where it was months ago, how agents are learning to debug and recover from failures, why combining screenshots with accessibility data, the DOM, Playwright, and generated code changes the speed equation, and why the next frontier is making agents literally superhuman at using software.
OpenAI clones Jev
In the second half, Nikunj Handa from OpenAI’s API team breaks down the new developer stack: async tool calling, mid-turn steering, WebSockets, UltraFast inference, the Decisions API, prompt caching, pre-warming, compaction, and the Agents API. Given that we were the first Jev podcast, we particularly focus on the unusually fast sprint on the Decisions API:
And why it is just a Luna wrapper for now but the team is motivated and egoless enough to clone what they consider to be good patterns.
We discuss:
- Why OpenAI thinks Computer Use has changed dramatically in just the last few months
- Dots and what changes when every agent gets its own Linux computer
- Why Computer Use can now complete some tasks faster than the average human
- The path from human-level to “literally superhuman” computer use
- Why modern agents are much better at debugging and recovering from failure
- How screenshots, accessibility trees, the DOM, Playwright, and generated JavaScript work together
- App Shots and why they give models much richer context than ordinary screenshots
- Why Computer Use can close the loop between writing software and testing it
- Trust, permissions, and safety when agents can make payments and operate websites
- Async function calling and why models no longer need to stop reasoning while tools run
- Mid-turn steering, WebSockets, and the architecture behind more responsive agents
- UltraFast inference and how OpenAI is pushing frontier models toward much lower latency
- The rapid internal story behind the Decisions API
- Why Decisions API is more than structured outputs at low latency
- GPT Live, fast tool calling, and real-time computer control
- How OpenAI is already using Decisions API for support classification and internal workflows
- Longer prompt caching, cache pre-warming, and cache-aware applications
- Server-side compaction vs manual compaction for long-running agent threads
- What should live inside an Agents API versus a developer’s own harness
- OpenAI as an “AI cloud” and the search for higher-level primitives beyond raw model APIs
Ari Weinstein
- Product & Engineering, Computer Use at OpenAI
- X: https://x.com/AriX
- LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/weinsteinari/
Nikunj Handa
- Product, API at OpenAI
- X: https://x.com/nikunjhanda
- LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/nikunjhanda/
Timestamps
00:00:00 OpenAI DevDay: Dots, GPT-6.1, Agents API, and Decisions API
00:02:52 Dots and Personal Cloud Computers
00:04:59 Why Computer Use Is “180 Degrees Different”
00:06:04 From Sky to Self-Debugging Computer Use Agents
00:09:24 How Computer Use Sees and Operates Software
00:12:09 From Faster Than Humans to Superhuman Computer Use
00:16:03 Agents API: Trust, Permissions, and Safety
00:17:31 Computer Use for Coding, Testing, and QA
00:19:14 GPT-6 APIs, Async Tool Calling, and UltraFast Inference
00:23:21 The Rapid Story Behind Decisions API
00:25:32 What Decisions API Is and How It Works
00:30:24 What OpenAI Is Building With the New APIs
00:32:23 Prompt Caching, Pre-Warming, and API Performance
00:35:20 Context Compaction for Long-Running Agents
00:37:13 Memory, Higher-Level APIs, and the AI Cloud
Transcript
Introduction: OpenAI DevDay and the New Agent Stack
Vibhu [00:00:00]: Okay. We’re very excited to be here. Today is OpenAI DevDay. Special podcast
Swyx [00:00:08]: We’re the first podcast after your livestream.
Vibhu [00:00:10]: First podcast. We have Ari here, who leads the product and engineering team for Computer Use agents. Before we kick in and dive deep on Computer Use, you wanna give a quick recap? What was announced? What’s the quick slew of announcements you guys had today?
Ari Weinstein [00:00:24]: Yeah. yeah, it was a super exciting day. we just got out of the keynote. It was really sick. there were a bunch of Computer Use announcements that I think are worth thinking about. We have, Dots, which is the new, sort of personal assistant product, and, that has some really exciting Computer Use features. There’s GPT-6.1 Sol, which is this amazing new model, that I think is particularly great for Computer Use ‘cause of, sort of the cost and speed, advantages. I think, I think we shared that it’s, a fifth of the cost of Astra and a seventh of the cost if you’re looking at Computer Use specifically, which is really amazing. sorry, there were so many things. I’m trying to sort through it.
Swyx [00:01:02]: And the API.
Ari Weinstein [00:01:03]: Agents API, which now has Computer Use in it, which is really cool, ‘cause now developers can build on the same Computer Use, that is part of Codex, and ChatGPT. and then there were some demos of our existing Computer Use features, like app shots, where you can take the context of something you’re doing on your computer and bring it into Codex and ChatGPT really fast. And then, like, native Computer Use on your Mac, where Roman had it taking screenshots of his app, automatically, and he could do other things on his computer while Computer Use was using his applications. so yeah, really exciting keynote.
Swyx [00:01:35]: And not to mention the Decisions API.
Ari Weinstein [00:01:37]: Decisions API.
Swyx [00:01:38]: Off the bat, are they all the same model? Like, this is. Or the same dataset distilled to different models?
Swyx [00:01:44]: Like, basically, like, is Computer Use using Decisions API, or are they, like, kinda separate?
Ari Weinstein [00:01:49]: So what’s really cool about the Decisions API is it, you know, it has all these new capabilities. It does inference in parallel. it doesn’t have reasoning. It’s a smaller model, than the ones we use for Computer Use. and so those capabilities make it really fast.
Dots and Delegating Work to a Cloud Computer
Swyx [00:02:07]: Yeah.
Ari Weinstein [00:02:07]: They also make it a little bit less good at doing, like, long horizon, sort of sophisticated tasks. And so I think I would say it’s still an open area of research for how we, like, bring those approaches together. But, yeah, I’m really excited to see what people build with the Decisions API.
Vibhu [00:02:24]: One of the interesting things is Dots now have attached personal computers.
Ari Weinstein [00:02:28]: Yeah.
Vibhu [00:02:28]: So it seems like they’re very much more persistent. You’ve been using them for a while. How should people push the bounds? Like, what should people aim for? What should they try? Personally, right now I use it for a lot of customer service. Like
Ari Weinstein [00:02:41]: Cool
Vibhu [00:02:41]: “Oh, this was wrong. I don’t wanna sign in. I don’t wanna authenticate.” Find whatever and just get it fixed.
Ari Weinstein [00:02:45]: Yeah.
Vibhu [00:02:46]: How should we push further? What should people try?
Ari Weinstein [00:02:50]: Dots Are a